High School

The Palo Duro Preacher: Eric Mims's Long Road Home

Nov 19, 2026, 2:00 PM

Amarillo Palo Duro alum Eric Mims has led the Dons to back-to-back 10-win seasons for the first time in school history while pastoring at his late father's church.

The Palo Duro Preacher: Eric Mims's Long Road Home

Eric Mims only ever knew his father as a pastor. 

As a toddler, his first memories are of driving two hours on a Sunday morning from his hometown of Amarillo to his father’s church in Childress, Texas. One day, that church switched to Borger, then Plainview, pinballing around the Panhandle as Pastor James M. Mims followed God’s calling for his life.

But young Eric didn’t share that calling, or so he thought. Those pre-dawn car rides are a perfect metaphor for Eric’s faith at that point. He wasn’t the one driving; his father was. Which is good, because Eric was just eight years old and would’ve been a horrible driver. But spiritually, Eric was simply along for the ride.

“For the longest time, that’s just what my parents did,” Mims said. “That was my parents’ religion. Yes, I’m here every Sunday and Wednesday. I sing in the youth choir and all that stuff. But that’s more or less because in the Black Baptist Church, we call them drug babies. We were drug to every service. We were drug out of bed. We were drug every night to church.”

His father had a lot of rules, but the most important one was Joshua 24:15: ‘As for me and my house, we will serve the Lord.’ So Eric did, dutifully. And then, when he moved out of his father’s house to play college football in Eastern New Mexico, he tried doing it his own way. No more midnight curfew. No more Dad telling him to get off the phone after a certain hour. He still went to church, but it was more ritual than spiritual.

Then, as a senior in college, Eric’s dad asked him to lead a guest sermon at the church he’d founded in Amarillo, New Covenant Missionary Baptist Church. The only issue was Eastern New Mexico’s Saturday night football game, and Eric was the starting cornerback. So, early the next morning, just like he used to do as a toddler, Eric drove two hours from Eastern New Mexico back to Amarillo for church. Except now he was in the driver’s seat. 



Eric’s heart pounded as he ascended the stage in front of a packed audience. He nervously shuffled his notes at the lectern, clearing his throat for the thousandth time. Then, he made a joke about his arm being in a sling. That week in practice, he’d dove to block a field goal and dislocated his shoulder. The crowd cackled as he re-enacted the injury. In that moment, Eric Mims merged faith and football, and they’ve been intertwined in his life ever since.

Eric Mims is the first Black athletic director in Amarillo ISD history and the head football coach of the 10-1 Palo Duro Dons, fresh off back-to-back district championships for the first time since 1970. But he’s also a pastor at his family’s church, preaching two Sunday sermons a month and leading Wednesday night youth groups. It’s a resume that’s as impressive as it is exhausting. Add in his five kids and a wife working on her master’s degree, and Mims has resigned himself to resting when he dies.

“Every time I see everything that he’s doing, it makes me feel lazy,” Palo Duro offensive coordinator Joe Hawthorne said. “I’m like, ‘I’ve got to step it up.’”

But for all Eric Mims does, he doesn’t consider himself actually “doing” anything. Really, God is doing all these things through him. He doesn’t mean that in a cocky way. He’s no prophet. He just means that God can always find an extra hour in the day for him, an anecdote from football practice he can use in a sermon, or a Bible verse from his pastoral studies that can motivate his team before a playoff game. Much like that first time preaching with a dislocated shoulder, there is no separation between preaching and coaching. Everything falls under the umbrella of his calling.  

“Being at the school house every single day is my full-time ministry,” Mims said. “I think I have more impact on kids five days a week than I would on just Wednesday night and Sunday morning.”

Eric Mims inherited his love for Palo Duro High School from his family as much as he did his faith.

His dad is enshrined in the school’s Athletic Hall of Fame, a rangy defensive end who set the Sun Bowl record in El Paso with a 48-second 400M sprint. His mother, Joyce Mims, started Palo Duro’s girls’ track and field program in 1974 and taught English there for 29 years. Eric and his three siblings all graduated from Palo Duro.

After graduating from Eastern New Mexico State, Mims played arena football for the Amarillo Dusters in the Intense Football League. Mims might not have known it then, but the seeds of his coaching tenure at Palo Duro were sown back then. He was teammates with Palo Duro’s current defensive coordinator, Dannie Snyder, and his now brother-in-law Julian Reese, the father of Palo Duro star quarterback Deuce Reese. Together, they won the IFL Championship in 2004.

Reese remembers Mims sitting in the corner of the locker room reading his Bible while the other players trash-talked. A lot of his teammates were focused on winning that championship, earning the next contract, or getting that call to the NFL. In other words, they were living for the next thing. But Mims was already three steps ahead of them, manifesting what he has today.  

“This was my dream job when I started coaching 20 years ago,” Mims said. “I wanted to be the next Palo Duro head coach after Steve Parr. I wanted to be a pastor at my dad’s church. My life was built around being here in Amarillo.”

Mims moved to the metroplex to coach under the legendary Reginald Samples at Dallas Skyline. But, all the while, he kept an eye on Parr’s 17-year run at Palo Duro, wondering if this would be the year the long-time head coach called it a career. After the 2015 season, he did, and Mims immediately reached out for an interview. He’d waited for this moment forever, working toward it while preaching with a sling and reading his Bible in the Amarillo Dusters locker room, and it was all about to come full circle.

But he didn’t get it.

Mims was upset, rejected by his family’s school. But he’d soon realize God’s timing was so much better than his own. Mims had tried leaving Reginald Samples’s staff at Duncanville after a 2-8 inaugural season in 2015. Instead, he stayed on as Duncanville’s offensive coordinator for five more seasons, going on a 61-8 run with two state championship appearances.

But more important than the wins, Samples taught Mims how to get the best out of his staff as a head coach. If Mims’s offense scored 50 points, Samples pointed out how they could’ve scored 70. If Mims’s offense scored 70, Samples highlighted the three blocks they missed. Some coaches would balk at a bar they could never reach, but those coaches don’t want to be the best. Even today, Mims finds himself scouring the records of all the current head coaches who worked for Samples, not wanting to be in the bottom half and letting the man down.  

“There’s always something that we should’ve done better,” Mims said. “You’ll never be content working for him. I love it. I don’t want to go somewhere and be happy to be there, relaxed, and told you’re doing a great job. I want you to challenge me to be better every day.”

Maybe that’s why Mims left a Duncanville program reaching the pinnacle of Texas high school football in 2021 to become the head coach at Palo Duro, a school that hadn’t had a winning season in six years. But, frankly, Palo Duro wasn’t the only place that needed help. 



Eric’s father, Pastor James M. Mims, passed away in 2018. He left behind a loving wife, four children, and New Covenant Missionary Baptist Church, a house of worship built in his image. The church’s motto was ‘If one hurts, we all hurt. If one wins, we all win.’ James lived the same way, always having three nicknames for everyone he met, making even a passing acquaintance feel like a dear friend.

“You would see all kinds of people from all walks of life coming to talk to him – from the street life to the pastors – and he treated everyone the same,” Julian Reese said.

After James’s passing, his wife, Joyce, became the church’s senior pastor. But James was such a massive personality that one person couldn’t replace him.

“We had big shoes to fill,” Joyce said. “He wore a size 12, and I wear a size eight.”

She needed Eric, but she also didn’t know if Eric would leave a Duncanville team at the height of its powers for Palo Duro, a school that had already scorned him.

“I didn’t think Eric would come back,” Joyce said. “I think the one thing that really drove Eric back here was the fact that his daddy had left the church to him. The whole time that we were in the ministry, he always told Eric, ‘When I leave, this is gonna be your church.’”

Now that you know Mims’s history, it makes sense why he went from Duncanville to Palo Duro. What’s crazier is how he got his offensive coordinator, Joe Hawthorne, to leave his post as Duncanville’s offensive line coach to move his new wife out to Amarillo, and then convinced his old arena teammate, Dannie Snyder, to leave an Amarillo Tascosa program coming off the state semifinals to be his defensive coordinator.

“This is a man of his word,” Snyder said. “We’re going into battle together. I know he ain’t going to stab me in the back, and I know we’re building something. It’s a totally different feeling when you build it from the ground up.”

These coaches got to Tascosa and Duncanville after the programs achieved success, then were critical components in helping them sustain it. Turning Palo Duro into a winner would be far more satisfying, but it’d also be far more difficult.

Palo Duro started the 2021 season on a 4-0 tear, but it turned out to be Fool’s Gold. The Dons dropped five of their final six games, including losses to neighborhood schools like Tascosa, Amarillo High and Caprock. The Palo Duro program was in a vicious cycle: blowout losses to other city high schools convinced the best athletes from their Northside neighborhood to move away before high school, which led to more losses, which led to more moves. To stop the trend, Mims launched the Neighborhood Heroes campaign, visiting all the Northside middle schools to convince kids they could succeed right where they grew up.

“With him being from here and people knowing about his family church and knowing his reputation, people listened and believed in him,” Hawthorne said. “They kept their kids here instead of sending them across town. So it almost felt like it had to be him to do what we did.”

But being known was Mims’s biggest blessing and curse. He had two of the most high-profile jobs in the city, pastor and football coach, but he was also entirely accessible as a Palo Duro graduate. And once Palo Duro began keeping Northside kids, that created more competition on the roster and more chances that one of his longtime friends’ kids wouldn’t be able to start.

“He had to learn the fact that everyone wasn’t gonna like him, because he had to make hard decisions,” Snyder said. “That’s the thing that ate him up.”

Mims was losing some friends – which is hard with anyone to grapple with, much less a pastor – and losing more games on the field than he wanted. When he took the Palo Duro job, he’d told Hawthorne that in three years they should be playing South Oak Cliff in the state semifinals. But the Dons didn’t have a winning season in his first four years.

“They say fast success grows your ego, but slow success grows your character,” Hawthorne said. “These last six years have made me a better coach and better person. Looking back, I’m glad we didn’t come in and start dominating right away.”

Again, Mims had to be reminded that God’s timing is so much more rewarding than his own. Palo Duro’s back-to-back double-digit win seasons, the first in school history, have coincided with his son EJ and nephew Deuce’s junior and senior seasons. The coaching staff has invested in their senior class of 2027 since they were in 7th grade, watering a tree every day that’s now bearing fruit at the sweetest time for Mims.  

This is the most starpower Palo Duro has ever had. Reese is a Delaware quarterback commit with over 2,500 yards and 32 total touchdowns. His favorite target is Texas wide receiver commit Kyron Brown. Former First-Round NFL Draft pick Ziggy Hood coaches a defensive line that has 45.5 sacks in just 11 games. If the Dons beat Celina this week, it’ll be just the fourth time this program has ever advanced to the third round of the playoffs.

“We always say it takes the right people being here at the right time,” Mims said. “We think time and destiny met each other, and here we are with an amazing staff and amazing kids. I’m just honored to get to be the leader of it all.”

Everywhere Mims looks, there are reminders of family, from his players on the field to his mom in the stands to his father in the sky. Sometimes, he says a silent thank you to his dad for making him take the two-hour ride every Sunday morning to Church. He used to think Palo Duro and the church were his parent’s identity, something he would one day outgrow. Somewhere along the drive, he took the steering wheel and found his way back home.

“Sometimes I sit back and say, ‘Oh, I wish your daddy could see what you’re doing now,’” Joyce said.